Having a website that ranks well in search engines is crucial for driving traffic and leads in the digital age. But many sites inadvertently sabotage their own SEO efforts through a problem known as keyword cannibalization. In this post, we’ll explore what exactly keyword cannibalization is, the primary causes, impact, and most importantly - how to fix it.

What Is Keyword Cannibalization?

Keyword Cannibalization refers to a situation where multiple pages on the same website compete against each other for the same keyword targets and search rankings. This internal competition fragments the authority and dilutes the optimization signals, preventing any single page from reaching its highest potential ranking.

Instead of complementing each other for better overall visibility, the pages end up cannibalizing domain authority and on-page optimization strength. This symmetric distribution of power ensures no single URL can dominate the SERPs (search engine results pages), limiting potential organic traffic.

Common Causes Of Keyword Cannibalization

There are a few common root causes of Keyword Cannibalization:

  • Duplicate Content Pages - Copying blocks of text across multiple on-site pages artificially inflates thin content while making it difficult for search engines to discern relevance. Even pages with entirely unique information will struggle if targeting identical keyword themes.
  • Overzealous Keyword Targeting - Including the exact same primary keywords on multiple pages splits relevance signals. Similarly, targeting close semantic variations like “internet marketing”, “online marketing”, “digital marketing” also indicates theme overlap.
  • Thin Informational Silos - Having many narrow pages targeting the same keyword dilutes page-level authority vs one comprehensive, authoritative resource. For example, keyword targeting “brand management” across pages for social media branding, label branding, personal branding, etc.
  • Uncoordinated Content Creation - Lacking centralized oversight of keyword targeting during content development frequently results in fragmentation. Various writers independently optimizing for similar terms compounds the problem.

Impacts Of Keyword Cannibalization

The negative effects of Keyword Cannibalization include:

  • Lower maximum ranking potential for all competing pages
  • Reduced aggregate organic traffic to the site
  • Wasted optimization effort better spent elsewhere
  • Confused click paths from search to site
  • Brand credibility damage from thin, duplicate content

In essence, self-inflicted SEO mistakes undermine the time invested in content creation, link building and technical website optimization.

Fixing Keyword Cannibalization Issues

While preventing keyword cannibalization is ideal, sites often already suffer from this issue before recognizing it. Here are some tips to help remedy existing problems:

  • Consolidate Content - Where possible, merge thin pages targeting the same keywords into one comprehensive, authoritative resource. Consolidation conveys greater relevance signals.
  • Refresh Redirects - For eliminated pages, set up 301 redirects pointing users and search engines towards the consolidated destination receiving merged content.
  • Expand Informational Breadth - Avoid simply duplicating the same content across larger pages. Add context, insight and utility while carving distinct keyword niche targets.
  • Coordinate Ongoing Efforts - Centralize keyword targeting alignment, content development and optimization initiatives across teams to minimize fragmentation.

Identify Gaps, Not Overlaps - Proactively pinpoint coverage gaps where no pages currently target relevant search queries and themes. Develop content for those untapped targets rather than piling on more pages competing for existing, over-optimized keywords.

Moving Forward With Coordinated Keyword Targeting:

Eliminating or minimizing Keyword Cannibalization relies first on recognizing when it is occurring. Monitoring relative search visibility and rankings across your own site’s pages for target keywords helps detect self-competition.

Ongoing coordination around content development and optimization supported by rigorous keyword research prevents backsliding. Focus on carving distinct, non-overlapping themes for each page to attract segmented search audiences.

With a robust methodology for expanded keyword reach and relevance refinement in place, consolidated pages can stretch for higher rankings without internal competition dragging them down. Resolution begins with a synchronized targeting strategy and an outside-in perspective revealing on-site fragmentation.

If tackling these complex optimization challenges independently would only lead to more wheel spinning, consider leveraging Gushwork to power your growth. Their unique human + AI approach helps build sustainable systems so you can concentrate on running your business, not just working in it.

Real Humans. AI-augmented.
Delegate workflows & beyond.

Book a Call to Get Started in 24hrs

Book a call now